One To Watch | Simracing604 On The Best Sounding Racing Sim

The awesome Simracing604 has been at it again today, releasing an interesting new video as he looks to compare audio of two popular, and widely regarded as best sounding, racing simulations.

In this new video, the smooth tones of Mike at Simracing604 looks into the topic of racing car engine audio representations in two specific simulations - RaceRoom Racing Experience and Assetto Corsa Competizione - both widely regarded by the sim racing community as at the very peak of audio excellence in our genre.


Mike explores how both games represent the virtual counterparts they are attempting to simulate, and ponders that all important question - which one is best?

Want to see more from Simracing604? Check out his excellent YouTube channel: click here.

Raceroom Racing Experience Screenshot 2020.11.30 - 05.45.03.38.jpg
 
RaceDepartment Editor-in-Chief, occasional YouTuber, commentator and broadcaster, with a passion for motorsport on both the real and virtual racetrack.

maranello78

250RPM
Oct 14, 2008
261
714
Raceroom is another great sim, and it sound and jobs feel great on every car
Last car i drove was 911 classic Cup and Ford capri and both is music to my ears.
Assetto Competizione for me is another great, and every car has its own personality. We are living a happy age for simracing and how they grab motorsports sounds making music for every fan
 

tlsmikey

500RPM
Feb 24, 2016
752
531
45
Been a while since i've played R3E but the sound was better than I remember in that video. ACC still the leader for me in sound though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ast654

rikirk

500RPM
Premium
Jan 11, 2017
542
278
I still have the same wish I had last year about Kunos considering a new sound take for the 488 which is far enough from reality to make it noticeable.
 

Demichkd

25RPM
Jun 25, 2019
36
134
All cars considered the edge for me goes to R3E. ACC combines amazing sound with gameplay to match on a more refined scope. Neither leaves me wanted more from the sound dept.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anthony monteil
Jun 4, 2017
19
18
36
Both sims are great depending on which car you choose. BMW M6 in ACC sounds more realistic (correct gearbox sound) while Bentley sounds more realistic in RaceRoom (except gearbox sound). It's a pity you didn't mention the WTCC and WTCR class, which NO OTHER sim on the market except RaceRoom has. In these classes, the RaceRoom sound is a masterpiece!!!

Ps. In terms of sounds, there is still a lot to do and I hope that both sims will improve sound positioning in 5.1, 7.1 multi-channel systems. I miss the positioning of Automobilista 1. On a perfectly calibrated system, the sound of the engine is always heard more from the front, regardless of whether you are driving a Mercedes or a Porsche. It should not be like that...
 
Last edited:

Cote Dazur

SIM Addict
May 21, 2013
2,036
2,159
Thank you for this excellent video comparison.

To me, it clearly shows how fortunate we are to have fantastic sound in modern SIM's, as I also appreciate the sound in AC, both official and mods and also the sound in AMS2.

As to which one I prefer between R3E and ACC, I like them both, to me R3E is rounder, dare I say more analog, :redface:, and ACC is more alive, crispier but also more synthetic, dare I say more digital, :redface::redface:
I am not the one for replay, so 99% of my sound SIM experience is inboard in VR.
If all aspect of SIM racing in 2020 was as good as the sounds we are getting, SIM racing would be even more immersive than it already is, most developers have it nailed in my book.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anthony monteil

fatal4you

250RPM
Oct 28, 2018
286
377
I like regular Assetto Corsa, furthermore I demand a law that legally requires all car manufacturers to have their past and present car lineup to be present in AC as mods.
 

BP

1000RPM
Premium
Nov 1, 2016
1,355
1,364
Haven't watched the video yet, but from my experience, ACC is probably my favorite overall but iRacing's sounds are also very good as well, especially since they started adding more environmental and paddock sounds in the mix. R3E was the best for a long time but I don't know if that still holds true today.

Edit: didn't realise only ACC and R3E were the ones being compared...but I still stand by my statement though; especially in that video ACC has more nuance and depth to the engine growl and the track sounds (curbs, gravel) are more defined (whether that's true to life or not I don't know). R3E definitely has more weight in the low end, but ACC is more balanced and beats it in the midrange details.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Adyl

Andrew_WOT

4000RPM
May 11, 2014
4,862
2,743
I like regular Assetto Corsa, furthermore I demand a law that legally requires all car manufacturers to have their past and present car lineup to be present in AC as mods.
Fonsecker mod was very good, also the latest RSS GTM Lanzo (Lambo) is pure music to the ears.
Both ACC and R3E feature great sound, nothing to complain really, just different presentation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ami_M3 and Adyl

harryturtle

10RPM
Dec 27, 2010
24
16
3RE.

Left iracing around 2 years ago to the bad sound for my ears and iR XAudio2 has not convinced me yet to come back.
 

roadyroad

250RPM
Dec 7, 2013
397
244
42
ACC's sounds still receiving a bathroom reverb effect, although the samples sound great, can't beat raceroom for me. I understand why Kunos did that but it is not the right reverb setting imo.

I haven't noticed that some samples in raceroom have received the same bathroom reverb treatment though. I heard one in this video. Maybe it's because I've watched it on my phone, but mixing sounds with that much difference of reverb is not good.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Shovas

DrRob

500RPM
Jan 7, 2017
924
777
45
I would tend to vote for R3E, but there is too much reverb for my taste.
For me both are currently at the top, no need to crown ONE winner as they mostly cater to different audiences anyway.