Two or Three Pedals - What Do You Prefer?

Two or Three Pedals on Your Sim Racing Rig.jpg

How many pedals do you prefer?


  • Total voters
    411
Sim racing rigs are as diverse as the people behind their racing wheels: Everyone has different preferences, which results in different hardware combinations and setups. As modern racing cars use paddles to shift gears, the clutch pedal is an increasingly rare sight in cockpits both on track and in homes - do you still insist on a third pedal?

Image credit: Fanatec

For many racing cars, the clutch is only needed to get moving from a standstill - which is then often handled either by automatic systems as found in GT3 cars like the Audi R8 LMS GT3 Evo II, Lamborghini Huracán GT3 EVO2 or Porsche 911 GT3 R (992), or via clutch paddles on the steering wheel. In Formula cars, this happened in the 1990s already to use less space for the footwell, but it has become standard in almost every modern racing car today.

Modern Days, Modern Solutions​

Manual shifting is mostly for enthusiasts in sim racing these days, and those who do will rely on a pedal-operated clutch. They often have to order an additional pedal if they spring for a new set, as many models come with just a throttle and brake - so it is not necessarily surprising that many sim racing rigs only feature two pedals.

Knowing the coordination and dance moves on the pedals needed to put it together, this lap by Ayrton Senna is even more impressive.

While it is possible to drive cars that use an H-shifter with paddles as well thanks to clutch assists, many drivers rarely do - or at least not often enough to warrant the addition of a clutch pedal or a shifter - and go with two pedals as a result. Some even build their rigs specifically to resemble the cockpit of certain cars or types of cars.

How About You?​

We want to know: How many pedals do you prefer on your rig? Is a clutch a necessity for your, or are you doing fine without one? Let us know in the comments below and in the poll!

Editor's Take​

As someone who enjoys both modern and vintage content, a clutch pedal and H-shifter are indispensable for my rig. I tend to drive cars with the type of transmission they actually had, so racing a 1967 Formula One car with paddle shifters, for example, simply does not feel right to me. Manual sequential cars are similar, and I enjoy those massively, too.

On the other hand, it is completely understandable if someone decides against a clutch pedal. It is often cheaper to just get two pedals - certainly once the higher end of the line is reached - to go racing, especially if they know that they are not going to use the extra pedal. Clutch paddles are also available for or with many wheels these days, so the need for the clutch assist to get moving after pit stops, for example, is also eliminated.

In the end, it is a subjective call - if you know that older cars do not interest you, you might as well go with two pedals. If you are on the fence or racing vintage vehicles only sometimes, not grabbing a clutch pedal might bar you from taking in the full experience later on, although most pedal sets can be updated with a third pedal at a later point.
  • Like
Reactions: astra52
About author
Yannik Haustein
Lifelong motorsport enthusiast and sim racing aficionado, walking racing history encyclopedia.

Sim racing editor, streamer and one half of the SimRacing Buddies podcast (warning, German!).

Heel & Toe Gang 4 life :D

Comments

Three. While I usually race cars that only require two pedals, and I can use the clutch on my GSI wheel, all of my cars are set up for the clutch pedal as I prefer it over the clutch on the wheel.

When I do choose to use a car that needs three pedals I have it available, along with the shifter.
 
Three, only because I still love driving some road cars with the pedal clutch. A week of driving without a terrifying hotlap in the '16 Viper ACR Extreme is no week of driving at all for me.
 
Owned a g27 for 12 years. Rarely used the clutch. Bought the MOZA R5 bundle with brake mod 3 months ago. I don't mis the clutch and if I would need a clutch i will asign it to a button on the wheel
 
Keen to classic cars through five decades (or rather since a kid in the 70ies, glancing classic cars magazines) and only drive dog box -/automatic gear vehicles on a rental basis, having owned solely H-stick cars since taking my drivers licence in 1990, besides learned heel&toe technique by my driving instructor back then in his E30, the answer is self-evident in my case :inlove:

So speaking simracing still can't fathom my switch to 3-pedals was as late as in 2011*, acquiring my G27 set, now primary T-LCM along my G27 pedals (still going strong though heavy use after just tiny services through the years) together with my T300RS-GT, delivering plenty of fantastic classic simracing.

* OK, in fact my memory now recalls using the auto clutch = off option in rFactor when title was released, this together with my Thrustmaster Guillemotte Ferrari FFB 2-set paddle design, the one set with variable input, hence using feeding in gear via mapping clutch to variable paddle, just as you watched disabled race pilots in dedicated race cars, as e.g. Jason Watt winning national pinnacle standard car series DTC.
And later when 2-pedal design broke down for my Guillemotte wheel, then just on/off clutch for other paddle set and gas/brake mapped to variable paddle set.

Oh, and remember using heel&toe technique on occasions as well with my Guillemotte Ferrari FFB wheel, this by mapping brake to the wheel's left variable input pad.
 
Last edited:
"Manual shifting is mostly for enthusiasts in sim racing these days, and those who do will rely on a pedal-operated clutch. They often have to order an additional pedal if they spring for a new set, as many models come with just a throttle and brake - so it is not necessarily surprising that many sim racing rigs only feature two pedals."

WHAT... drugs are you on??? All the big names in the industry offer sim racing rigs that have 3 pedals as standard!! It's the other way around. if you only want 2 pedals for some reason, in most cases you'd need to buy an additional 2 pedal set for that purpose.
 
When sim racing my left knee doesn't agree to using a clutch anymore, it gets sore in the heat of the battle, so it's got to be only 2 pedals for me.
Otherwise I'd be using a clutch when needed for immersion and I'd be all over this... :geek:
 
Premium
I usually drive Group-C and BPR cars, so a clutch is a must. I can transform my H-pattern shifter into a sequential one within seconds, and the rare occasion i drive with paddle shifters i don't use the clutch unless it's to prevent the engine from stalling after a spin.
 
Premium
Hello friends of fast vehicles.
I personally prefer 3 pedals, but each as he wants.
The reason is as follows.
As a fan of historic vehicles and racetracks,
I have a historic variant of Assetto Corsa. No modern content inside.
I love this era of motorsport.
Clutch is simply part of it and you scrap the engine in Assetto Corsa anyway.
I even go so far as to move the gear stick from right to left when driving British vehicles. Depending on whether I drive touring cars or monoposti,
I even change my pedals from hanging to lying. For me, that is simply part of a simulator.
This is the only way I can also haptically simulate the selected vehicle.
The pedal does not behave like a clutch?
I solved it like this and it feels pretty similar anyway.
Adjust the pedal travel so that it is not linear. Now let the pedal travel start at 20%, done.
You can still take it to the extreme. Craftsmanship required.
Back then I put socks behind the brake pedal on my G25 to regulate the brake pressure.
Where is the, of course, new sock now?
 
  • Like
Reactions: pai
I wonder if three pedals and shifters are profitable in controllers industry. Controllers industry controls simracing industry.
 
Last edited:
On a three-pedal setup, you can use two pedals. On two pedals setup, you cannot use three pedals :D So that is easy.
I remember upgrading my Logitech MOMO to Logitech DFP. I left the MOMO connected just to be able to use two sets of "two-pedal" bases. To be able to use the Gas pedal from the old Wheel as a clutch :D
 
Premium
4 pedals...
Gas
Brake (inverted)
Clutch (inverted)
Dead Pedal... need some place to put my foot while not shifting...
 

Latest News

Article information

Author
Yannik Haustein
Article read time
3 min read
Views
6,670
Comments
56
Last update

To join the OverTake Racing Club races I want them to be: (multiple choice)

  • Free to access

    Votes: 100 91.7%
  • Better structured events

    Votes: 18 16.5%
  • Better structured racing club forum

    Votes: 17 15.6%
  • More use of default game content

    Votes: 14 12.8%
  • More use of fixed setups

    Votes: 31 28.4%
  • No 3rd party registration pages

    Votes: 39 35.8%
  • Less casual events

    Votes: 10 9.2%
  • More casual events

    Votes: 35 32.1%
  • Other, specify in thread

    Votes: 5 4.6%
Back
Top