As the title says, how do you rate it?
lol, among the true rBelievers (of which I am not one, though I like it) this is heresy of the very very worst kind. Can see your point, though.
how on earth would i know? never even got close to the things. the fact that we do not see any newcomer clocking much the same time as yvan muller or rob huff rather seems to indicate that these are, like anything faster than a souped up family car, difficult to control in difficult situations, which real life racing is 98% of the time (else one wouldn't bother watching, one could also watch the cars go by on the motorway) there are indeed very few people out there who can control any racing car at top level, so any game really imitating the feel / physics would be bound to fail saleswise. i for one probably wouldn't enjoy it.
the average family saloon has between 70 - 110 Bhp.
S2000 spec touring cars run at 300Bhp.
considerable difference i'd say