Now buying a new (to you) car is for sure going to bring up biased people, what it comes down to is which car you like. I will admit before I got my PT I was looking heavily into ZX2's as well (I wanted a 5 speed one, most were in that fire engine red as well). Its also that some people live in different parts of the world so prices for specific vehicles may be different then in other parts of the world.
But my PT besides oil changes and tires and lower control arm bushings. hasn't been much of a problem really. (lower control arm bushings are quite common on them). gas mileage isn't impressive at all, I'm achieving 19mpg in the city, but I should note I have aftermarket wheels that are heavier then factory.
That's what I'm worried about. MPG's for the PT aren't that great.....
The Neon, I've never seen it as a bad car myself as far as I know it gets pretty good gas mileage its good on power, and I'd imagine its a bit better in the turns then the PT lol.
1st Gen Neons are awesome. 2nd gen Neons don't handle anywhere near as well.
Now being who I am and being a bit of a Ford fan (of their current products at least). I know the 2nd gen Focus (or is it 3rd gen here not sure, 08-11 models though), those were based on the Mazda 3 platform, and they drive very nice. the older ones I didn't like the styling so much nor the driving position, but from what I've heard good little cars.
The US (I live in Ohio, not somewhere in France as people like to think......) Ford Focus has been the same from 2000-2011. We never got the MK2 Ford Focus which is shared with the Volvo S40 and Mazda 3. Our Ford Focus is essentially the same as it was when it was introduced in 2000 (Save for the switch from the ZETEC motors to the DURATEC motors). I prefer the 2000-2004 models, IMO they look the best.
The Mazda Protege looks good, not sure its really as reliable as the other ones though. but I'd imagine being a small car it handles itself quite well on the roads.
I dunno. My brother has an 02' Corolla, and it's pretty teensy inside. I prefer to sit more upright, something the Protege doesn't offer.
Hyundai's, boring but good cars as I've heard.
Honda Civic, my limited experience with a 4 cylinder Accord, was quite terrible. the car never would run quite right, but it was 10 years old.
That's new. Hondas have an excellent reputation for reliability....it's why Civics in particular are so expensive (in the used market) in comparison to other compacts.
Was it an Automatic Accord? I know that Honda had an issue with AT transmissions in the Accord.
I do have one suggestion not sure if its in your price range though 2o6, but might be worth a look (and if you got it I would officially envy you) is a Chrysler 300M, not really less disposable but one sweet car nonetheless one from about 2001 should be right in your price range. 300M Specials are a little more desirable, but not running for much more. as far as i know the trans in those is good, engine, good, suspension good. worst part is gas mileage, which is like mid 20 to low 20s.
Too big, and I need to change my own gears. No automatics.
You could always look at the cra... I mean Cavaliar though I've heard bad things about those.
Not a chance. The basic platform of the Cavalier was essentially unchanged since it's introduction 1983. Cheap, horrible in corners, noisy, unrefined, not that quick......