RD Tech Review | Fanatec CSL Elite McLaren GT3 V2 Wheel

[mrexcitement71]

I setup the car so 90 deg is full lock so i never have to remove my hands from the wheel and for me it works very well and gives me very fast control of the car.
Also have the handbrake as a button under my right thumb , again for very fast reactions.
Certainly puts a smile on my dial.

 

[RCHeliguy]

I setup the car so 90 deg is full lock so i never have to remove my hands from the wheel

Just like a real car!

 

[Helmut Skrdla]

No, sadly not. But even if you could get the wheel on the thrustmaster base, all buttons would be dead as fanatec decided to encrypt their signals to restrict their wheel to only fanatec wheelbases...
I know a lot of people using fanatec wheels with a dd wheel and a USB interface.
Sadly not possible anymore with newer fanatec wheels

Thanks for the detailed answer. Sucks a bit, because before I upgraded inside the TM ecosystem I looked at Fanatec and noticed this wheel v1 was no longer selling, which would have been the main reason to chose them...

 

[Chrhun]

I bought the new one even though I have the old one. I really want the shifter upgrade.

 

[eco2006]

I setup the car so 90 deg is full lock so i never have to remove my hands from the wheel and for me it works very well and gives me very fast control of the car.
Also have the handbrake as a button under my right thumb , again for very fast reactions.
Certainly puts a smile on my dial.

Have you tried using a controller, may be perfect for your use case?
Btt.: I got one as well and really looking forward to see my whole screen while driving.

 

[mrexcitement71]

I came from controllers , I was on consoles before jumping back to PC gaming and controllers just can't compare to my current Fanatec DD1 , He Pro pedal setup

 

[michelforest]

I ended up ordering it today. I always wanted that McLaren steering wheel, and with the addition of the magnetic shifters, and other improvements, it was a no brainer at that price.

 

[Lars Stjernstrøm]

I wonder if the QR2 will work with csl and clubsport wheels

 

[blekenbleu]

Several YouTube reviews remark on its exceptionally low weight revealing FFB microdetails.
Repurposed on an AccuForce or other (hybrid) stepper wheelbase, its reduced rotational inertial may allow cogging to be felt which is typically masked by most rims' flywheel effect...

I have no experience with Fanatec wheel bases.

 

[VernWozza]

Several YouTube reviews remark on its exceptionally low weight revealing FFB microdetails.
Repurposed on an AccuForce or other (hybrid) stepper wheelbase, its reduced rotational inertial may allow cogging to be felt which is typically masked by most rims' flywheel effect...

Personally have't felt the slightest hint of that on my wheel. Tried it on CSL Elite base and DD2.

 

[blekenbleu]

Personally have't felt the slightest hint of that on my wheel. Tried it on CSL Elite base and DD2.

Can you feel cogging by removing the rim and twisting the wheel base hub?
AccuForce cogging is quite distinctly felt then..

 

[RCHeliguy]

Can you feel cogging by removing the rim and twisting the wheel base hub?
AccuForce cogging is quite distinctly felt then..

While that is true of most all direct drive motors to some extent, it is a fallacy to extrapolate that there is any correlation in game. At rest vs. electrically active are completely different.

 

[blekenbleu]

While that is true of most all direct drive motors to some extent, it is a fallacy to extrapolate that there is any correlation in game. At rest vs. electrically active are completely different.

I agree that active FFB cogging differs from power off,
but with/without rim for power off is readily reproducible,
and rim rotational inertia effects apply in either case ..

 

[RCHeliguy]

I agree that active FFB cogging differs from power off,
but with/without rim for power off is readily reproducible,
and rim rotational inertia effects apply in either case ..

Now you get into slew rates and overall power and reaction times.

However a powerful DD wheel will just suck down a bit more current and move the extra weight.

 

[blekenbleu]

Now you get into slew rates and overall power and reaction times.

Indeed, gain/bandwidth and closed loop stability issues.

However a powerful DD wheel will just suck down a bit more current and move the extra weight.

.. so you suspect placebo effect in those YouTube reviews?
Cote Dazur noted that he affected subsequent DD1 behavior by dragging against its rim during calibration. Meanwhile, SimXperience recommends removing their wheel during calibration
(to avoid USB cable thrashing);
AccuForce force feedback presumably does not account for rim inertia,
unless they can sense back EMF during PWM off time to estimate loads
and/or back-calculate from encoder data, which would seem problematic,
since it only reports positional changes...?

 

[RCHeliguy]

I don't believe AccuForce makes a powerful DD wheel at this time.