I decided to do some online racing due to this thread, but I still prefer racing single player. Here is why.
1. Easier to find the race you want the way you want it.
2. With family, time can be limited, and it is still quicker to jump in a single player race.
3. No qualifying, waiting on other players, etc.
4. The AI is more considerate than many of the online players.
5. There is more punting than an American football game.
6. Just like single player you are penalized for someone else running into you. However, it is easier to avoid with the AI. And that is saying a lot with ACC and the AI punting it does.
7. The most aggressive driver (the punters) seems to win most of the races I have been involved in (Typically 15-30 min with qualifying), and I refuse to use that tactic to win.
8. Uncertainty of the expected etiquette. I did look this up, but there seems to be disagreements on this topic.
What I liked most about it.
1. Although there were many punters that seem to place highest with no regard for others, the ones that were respectful were fantastic. I saw one person punt another on accident, and he pulled over until that person was back on the track.
2. Less predictability from the drivers.
3. Being flabbergasted at how fast some of the online guys are. I enjoyed letting a faster driver pass, and then follow and copy the lines they were taking.
4. Has pushed me to look more at my car settings, as I can tell that some of the online people have definitely done some things to their cars to give that extra push. I typically go aggressive setting with change of tire pressure based on temps, brake change for shorter races (set to 1), and reduce fuel for shorter races.
I will probably do some more online stints, but will likely remain mostly offline. I am surprised that the SA rating of some of the players is as high as it is with all of the punting that is done. Maybe it is just the races I have been involved in. Since I am not that great of a sim racer this actually helps me some, as I get to pass those ahead of me that were punted, so I guess that is an upside to it
.