Should DRS be removed from Formula 1?

Should DRS go_.jpg

What are your thoughts on DRS?


  • Total voters
    801
With two races out of the way, we have experienced the new 2022 regulations and how the cars race. Should the Drag Reduction System (DRS) be removed from Formula 1 or be kept?

The 2022 regulations were a massive overhaul of the car regulations. The 2022 regulations which were originally slated for 2021 but were delayed due to the Covid-19 pandemic and have one major principle to allow cars to race closer.

With previous regulations, a following car would lose 35% of their downforce when racing within 20 metres of the car ahead. That loss of downforce could increase to 47% if the following car got within 10 metres of the car ahead.

The new regulations are meant to reduce the downforce lost and from what we have seen so far, the new regulations appear to work.

So now that we know cars are able to drive closer to each other, should we remove DRS?

Drag Reduction System (DRS) was introduced to F1 in 2011. DRS was implemented as a tool to allow cars to overtake. It is essentially an adjustable rear wing that is operated by the driver. DRS has strict conditions where the racing conditions must be safe and the pursuing car must be within a one second gap of the car in front as it crosses the DRS detection zone.

When it was introduced, it was met with a mixed reaction. Some thought it to be the solution to a lack of overtaking, whilst others thought it made overtaking too easy. Now that we appear to have cars that can drive closer to each other, surely this makes overtaking even easier?

Bahrain 2022​

During the first race of the season, we saw Charles Leclerc and Max Verstappen battling for the lead - before Max had to retire. During this race we appeared to see the immense advantage Max had over Charles along the start/finish straight. At times, Max was just within the one second gap that is required to activate DRS, yet was able to get to T1 first. However, DRS wasn’t quite as powerful as it first appeared here. After the race Charles Leclerc stated that he allowed Max to close the gap along the start/finish straight, so that he had DRS immediately after - which allowed him to hold onto the lead.

Bahrain DRS.jpg


Saudi Arabia 2022​

The second race of the season was at Jeddah and this is where we say a very peculiar thing indeed. Whilst battling for the lead, we saw Charles and Max both hit the brakes hard before entering the DRS detection zone for the start/finish straight. It would appear that whoever entered the final corner first would be at a massive disadvantage and could be easily overtaken. So the result saw both drivers braking heavily, trying to be the second car to enter the final corner. But, this race was more than just the DRS zones, it showed how well these cars can follow each other. Both the Ferrari and Red Bull were able to follow each other closely through most of the lap, which was not so easy in 2021 with the previous F1 regulations.

Jeddah DRS.jpg


Calls for a change to DRS​

Many fans have started to call for a change to the DRS rules and those calls for a change could be amplified further with this week’s race at Albert Park. The Australian GP has an unprecedented 4 DRS zones, one along the main straight, another between turns 2 and 3, the third between turns 8 and 9, and the fourth between turns 10 and 11.

Australia DRS.jpg


Here are our thoughts on some potential options for 2022.

Remove DRS completely. If DRS were to be removed completely, then there will be one certainty - less overtaking. DRS is there to help overtaking, so completely removing it will have an impact on the amount of overtakes that are seen during a race. Also, removing DRS will expose how well the F1 2022 regulation cars actually follow each other. There is also the cost to take into account as each team has a budget cap.

If DRS were to be removed, the rear wings may have to keep the DRS function for the remainder of the season. It also may not be as simple as removing the adjustable flap, as these wings will most definitely have been designed to optimise DRS in some way and so may need a complete redesign.
  • Pros - Real overtaking
  • Cons - Less overtaking and potential cost implication
Restrict the use of DRS. The main disadvantage of DRS is that it gives the driver behind an advantage over the driver ahead. However, this could be eradicated if the DRS detection zones were removed and drivers were allowed to use DRS whenever they liked - still with designated DRS zones. This would provide the driver ahead to have a way to defend from an overtaking car. It could also be used by drivers who are attempting to complete an over or undercut, by using DRS to put in a fast lap whilst other drivers are pitting.

The caveat to this is that there would be a limited number of times any one driver could activate DRS during a race.
  • Pros - allows driver ahead to defend and tactical use of DRS
  • Cons - still doesn’t address DRS being potentially overpowered
Leave it as it is. Whilst we are only two races into the season, removing DRS or changing the way it is utilised could be potentially unfair. There were 77 overtakes in Bahrain and 33 overtakes in Saudi Arabia - the majority of these overtakes would have been with the aid of DRS. This means that DRS is already a factor to the amount of points certain drivers have been rewarded and this includes Max Verstappen who may not have won the race at Jeddah without DRS.

Love it or hate it, DRS does provide more opportunities to overtake and without DRS there will be less overtaking. Less overtaking could have an impact on the global audience, especially affecting the audience who have only known F1 with DRS. A result of this could mean an impact on F1 financially - with less fans watching F1 and fewer companies willing to invest in the motorsport.

Finally, leaving DRS as it is allows the FIA to evaluate the entire season and to properly formulate a plan for 2023, if they chose to change DRS in some way in the future.

What are your thoughts about DRS? Should we keep it, change it, or leave it?
About author
Damian Reed
PC geek, gamer, content creator, and passionate sim racer.
I live life a 1/4 mile at a time, it takes me ages to get anywhere!

Comments

Sadly, DRS seems to be a necessity in today's cars. They produce a lot of downforce, while at the same time producing a lot of dirty air to the car(s) behind, making it impossible to overtake without removing drag somewhere/somehow.

The best F1 races I've seen were up until 2006 or so. After that it seems the sport focused more on qualy lap times than the actual racing - which is good for the teams but bad for spectators.

I wouldn't mind if we had V10-style cars back. Lots of top speed, quite a bit of downforce while not producing a lot of drag/dirty air, and many overtakes to come. Oh, and with slick tires of course ;)
 
I think from the first few races this year we've seen that cars can certainly get closer and stay closer through corners.

But as Russell said in testing, the slipstream effect is actually now less as the cars aren't punching that giant hole in the air that they used too, as all of that aero is now underneath the car and the dirty air is shooting nearly vertically away from the back of the car and not right in the face of the following driver.

There is no real shame in having DRS. I think we'd all be moaning for F1 to add some form of aid to overtake if it wasn't around right now.
 
I think from the first few races this year we've seen that cars can certainly get closer and stay closer through corners.

But as Russell said in testing, the slipstream effect is actually now less as the cars aren't punching that giant hole in the air that they used too, as all of that aero is now underneath the car and the dirty air is shooting nearly vertically away from the back of the car and not right in the face of the following driver.

There is no real shame in having DRS. I think we'd all be moaning for F1 to add some form of aid to overtake if it wasn't around right now.
Another problem that is not talked about anymore is the brakes, before there was a fight for those who brake later, who had the most courage to brake inside and overtake, today the drivers brake already turning the steering wheel to the curve, that's why "normal" overtaking also it got more difficult, maybe a decrease in braking performance would help, as the cars can follow each other closely, if the one behind can brake more inside he theoretically passes, we saw this in Imola when the DRS was still off, in turn 1 .

Alonso when he was at Ferrari said that disputes like Villeneuve x Arnoux would no longer occur, these long cars make the drivers have to always walk in the right line as possible to get performance, the short cars allow more pilots to have more control, even when recovering from an error, see Herta in Indianapolis last weekend, in an F1 it would be difficult to recover from the rear of that one.

Perhaps in 2026 if the size of the cars is reduced, as already mentioned by the FIA, which can go back to having the length of the V10 cars of the 2000s, the most skilful driver will be able to make an easier overtaking maneuver as before, the more bureaucratic will have more difficulty as it was before, see Prost.
 
In short, go back to iron brakes(increases braking distance), remove hybrid power units(shortens the wheelbase), & yeah that Herta video was amazing!(watch the entire outlap)
 
In short, go back to iron brakes(increases braking distance), remove hybrid power units(shortens the wheelbase), & yeah that Herta video was amazing!(watch the entire outlap)

So not F1 but some sort of retro racing league, that's not been tried before .... oh yes it has and fallen on its face every single time because no one watched.
 

Latest News

Article information

Author
Damian Reed
Article read time
5 min read
Views
19,890
Comments
146
Last update

How long have you been simracing

  • < 1 year

    Votes: 377 16.2%
  • < 2 years

    Votes: 257 11.0%
  • < 3 years

    Votes: 247 10.6%
  • < 4 years

    Votes: 181 7.8%
  • < 5 years

    Votes: 304 13.1%
  • < 10 years

    Votes: 261 11.2%
  • < 15 years

    Votes: 167 7.2%
  • < 20 years

    Votes: 129 5.5%
  • < 25 years

    Votes: 100 4.3%
  • Ok, I am a dinosaur

    Votes: 304 13.1%
Back
Top