Open Wheel or Tin Top - Which is Your Favorite?

McLaren MP4-12 720S GT4 BMW M4 GT4 Red Bull Ring Automobilista 2.jpg

Which type of car is your favorite to race in?

  • Open Wheel

    Votes: 166 31.6%
  • GT

    Votes: 155 29.5%
  • Touring Car

    Votes: 86 16.3%
  • Prototype

    Votes: 62 11.8%
  • Stock Car

    Votes: 13 2.5%
  • Rally

    Votes: 25 4.8%
  • Other (please comment)

    Votes: 19 3.6%

  • Total voters
    526
The great variety in motorsport and, as a result, in sim racing, offers plenty of choice for fans and virtual racers – not just when it comes to circuits. While the most popular form of racing in the world uses open wheel cars in Formula 1, GT and Touring Car racing also enjoy large followings, and sim racers seem to gravitate to tin tops more and more. And where do Prototypse rank in this?

Not only do the two types of cars look fundamentally different, they also present entirely different challenges to their drivers: While open wheelers are light, nimble, and relatively powerful, especially in the bigger series, GT cars tend to be heavier, not as fast, but suited to more drivers due to their ease of access. Meanwhile, Touring Cars are quite different yet again, as they often feature front-wheel drive as well as low power and require a lot of commitment to throw them around a circuit quickly.

Another popular class in sim racing also has enclosed wheels and a roof, but does not hande like anything else out there on road courses – and that is because they are mainly at home on ovals: Stock Cars, as raced by NASCAR, are heavy beasts, but their enormous V8 engines can extract a lot of speed out of these all-American machines that require a very particular set of skills to get the most out of them.

Prototypes - Intense Tin Tops?​

Somewhere in between open wheelers and GT cars, prototypes like the current LMH and LMDh Hypercars can be found: Designed for endurance racing, these vehicles have enormous downforce and tons of power at their disposal, meaning they are closer to a formula-style car than to a GT vehicle when it comes to driving them. Keeping this intensity up for longer periods of time presents its own challenge.

Arguably the most challenging type of racing does not even necessarily take place on paved roads: Rally drivers and their co-drivers face quick-fire action like no other racers, flying through forests on gravel roads, tarmac country roads or even sliding on snow and ice – no matter if it is raining or the sun is out. Even night stages are on the calendar, ramping up the intensity even more. Meanwhile, Rallycross takes place on closed circuits, but is different in nature due to multiple racers competing at the same time, contrary to classic rallys. Loose surface racing is not reserved to rallying, though: Dirt ovals are especially popular in a variety of vehicles in the US, and hillclimbs can also feature gravel roads.

Your Opinion​

There are countless forms of racing out there, so not every type has even been mentioned in this article. We want to know, though: What is your favorite type of car to get into the virtual cockpit of? Do you prefer open wheelers? Touring Cars? GT machines? Prototoypes? Rally? Or something entierely different? Let us know in the poll and in the comments below!
About author
Yannik Haustein
Lifelong motorsport enthusiast and sim racing aficionado, walking racing history encyclopedia.

Sim racing editor, streamer and one half of the SimRacing Buddies podcast (warning, German!).

Heel & Toe Gang 4 life :D

Comments

Touring cars for me, mainly because it was the first racing game I ever played (toca1 and 2 on ps1) and being British the biggest form of national motorsport and the best run race weekends in the UK has always been BTCC thanks to the main series plus its support races. That and in sim racing I've always been better and faster at racing fwd cars than I have rwd cars. I think sometimes it takes more to go properly quick in fwd than it does rwd.
 
Last edited:
Premium
Open wheelers and prototypes, I will drive gt but generally only if not a lot is happening on sessions with the cars i want.

I am not really in to the F1, I don't wan't to be making adjustments all the time so I have fun in open wheelers that less complex. I can handle something like push to pass and lmdh, lmp2 doesn't have constant button fiddling so they are fun as well.

Outside of the F1 series which for obvious reasons has only f1 cars it seems that most attraction with people who like open wheelers is not with that current top tier but with slower cars.
 
Premium
I tend to gravitate towards the open wheelers, Maybe because AMS2 does them so well and they have a good spread of content.

A couple of years ago when ACC was my daily it would have been GT's, Though if there was a dedicated fully featured Aussie game, it would be touring cars.

And it would have been Rally if I answered this question 5 years ago.

So, for me, it looks like depends on the game, so the real answer is Wreckfest.
 
My favorite type of car to race is "not open wheeler without top" (I voted "others"). I like to race without any pillar for better visibility and without roof for enjoying the screnary.
So cars like Shelby Cobra, Ferrari Monza SP, Ariel Atom, KTM XBow, Lotus Eleven, Maserati Tipo 61, Afla Tipo 33 even MX5s are what I like the most to race with.
Add the BAC mono and it could be my post :)
 
Last edited:
Difficult question, especially when each category could.be split into at least 2 categories : modern and historic, whichbalso would require to define what shoulf be considered as modern. I like all of these categories but I gave my vote to GT for all my memories of GTR2 (and so RSS GT and NGT mod). Ibenjoyed and still enjoy the great GT1s of Pcars 2 and now AMS2, the GTOs of Pcars2 and Raceroom, and all the classic cars of any racing sim, from GTL to AMS2, rfactor2, AC... Enduracers for rfactor2 is still a great mod I enjoy (and wait for the update bringing it to the current level of rfactor2). I almost forgot the group 5 cars, which are some of the best looking cars ever imo, and also some of the most insane to drive m. The only cars that I could compare to them are the amazing Can Am cars, which I consider as GT cars too (but maybe they are better in the prototype category).

Historic GT cars are heavy and powerful, and always a challenge they are fast enough to enjoy a good sensation of speed, but slow enough to be able to use them on many different tracks, short and long, they are beasts you race with and against at the same time, there isn't any full safe feeling about them.

The classic cars from the 60s and 70s are so diverse that it is hard to imagine some cars racing together but it worked fine.

Modern GT cars, well, they are less fun imo but I need to use GTE cars more often, which have more power and downforce than the GT3 (they are the replacement of the old GT2s). But the category will become part of the historic GTs next year if I'm not wrong.

EDIT : I myst admit that ultimately my most played cars are group C cars though :D
 
Last edited:
Rwd touring cars and sportscars from the days gone by. My ideal type of car has good amount of power, somewhat grippy tires and very modest downforce. Something like porsche rsr 3.0, porsche 2.0 911, trans-am cars of any era and so forth. And porsche cup car of any era. Pre 2000s sportscars also deserve a mention imho.

Those cars are slow enough so you can drive through every kind of corner without having to rely on reactions and memorization. But still fast and powerful enough to make every corner have clearly separated braking, entry, mid and exit parts of corners. When it breaks loose it is not gone instantly but still loose enough you have to keep it in mind and control.

I don't really like rally. I prefer to drive the same corners all the time other than listen a guy tell me where to turn and how fast. Open wheelers and protos are too twitchy and snappy for me and the modern ones way too setup reliant. Older protos are good fun tho, like porsche 962 and the mazda screamer. Modern gt is fun sometimes but I always find myself wanting a more analogue experience soon after driving one.
 
Premium
I have trouble picking a favorite so I chose other. I am not partial to one brand or type, it just depends on what I want to drive in the moment, or if I'm participating in an event, then what the event calls for.

I do however generally prefer classics over modern cars. To me that is anything 90s and earlier. Even with that said though, modern open wheelers, GT cars, prototypes, etc are all incredibly capable. A good example would be the 911 cup car, whatever generation. That car would probably make my top ten list of favorites if I were to really think about it.
 
Last edited:
Single seaters. But nowadays everybody seems to love the GT3, supercars and the JDM drift cars
 
I've never encountered an open-wheeler that wasn't a nervous skittish ballerina that wants to spin like a top if you breathe on the throttle too hard. Plus, I like being able to rub fenders with an opponent without my car exploding. Tin tops for me, and especially the heavy pigs like Nascar stock cars.

Exceptions are made for the low-powered downforce-deficient open wheelers like caterhams, or formula vees. Those are good fun. But downforce-heavy cars tend to have two modes of "all the grip" and "bald tires on an oil slick atop a glacier" and I just cannot stand that level of nervousness in my cars.
 
Premium
Prototypes, mainly the 1980's era. I grew up with a family that loves motorsports and i got hooked on the World Sports Prototype Championship because the regulations allowed a variety in cars, shapes, engines and configurations, and each car/configuration had its advantage or disadvantage according to the circuit and circumstances. The other reason is that they're actual cars that were close to being road legal, and the looks are simply stunning.
For the same reasons i love GT, and especially the BPR/FIA GT era. Lots of variety and a very interesting era with regards to the manufacturer's interpretation of the rules.
Both prototype and GT racing have a massive influence on modern transportation in terms of performance, materials, safety, aerodynamics and such. It fascinates me.
And also a bit for chauvinistic reasons; many of my fellow countrymen had a history in prototype and GT racing, and many of those cars are present in Assetto Corsa.
 
Prototypes, mainly the 1980's era. I grew up with a family that loves motorsports and i got hooked on the World Sports Prototype Championship because the regulations allowed a variety in cars, shapes, engines and configurations, and each car/configuration had its advantage or disadvantage according to the circuit and circumstances. The other reason is that they're actual cars that were close to being road legal, and the looks are simply stunning.
For the same reasons i love GT, and especially the BPR/FIA GT era. Lots of variety and a very interesting era with regards to the manufacturer's interpretation of the rules.
Both prototype and GT racing have a massive influence on modern transportation in terms of performance, materials, safety, aerodynamics and such. It fascinates me.
And also a bit for chauvinistic reasons; many of my fellow countrymen had a history in prototype and GT racing, and many of those cars are present in Assetto Corsa.
Imo the BPR era had the best car grids ever. They had everything, the look, the sound, the H pattern gear shifter, no driving helps: F40, Mclaren F1, Lotus Esprit GT1, Venturi 600, Mustang, Marcos LM600, Jaguar XJ220., Viper, Lister Storm, DeTomaso Pantera, Lamborghini Diablo, Porsche 911, Renault Sport Spyder, Toyota Sard ... there are too much and each of them looks like a beast. As much I like many other racing series and GT years, these 90s years are my favorite ones.
 

Latest News

Article information

Author
Yannik Haustein
Article read time
2 min read
Views
4,254
Comments
40
Last update

Are you buying car setups?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
Back
Top