1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
Dismiss Notice
Like RaceDepartment on Facebook.

Race #09, Valencia: Post Race Checks

Discussion in 'Formula SimRacing' started by Stefan Kanitz, Jun 27, 2010.

  1. Ajibola Lawal

    Log File: Ok
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: n/a
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Alberto De Juan

    Log File: Rearview="0"
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty: Warning for Log Infraction

    Andreas Nilsson

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Ben Phillips

    Log File: Ok
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Benjamin Chong

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Chris Knight

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: not used
    Penalty: DQ for not using Launch-Control

    Danny Roberts

    Log File: not received
    Pre-Qualifying: not received
    Qualifying: not received
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty: DQ for missing Log File, Start from the Back of the Grid for missing Qualifying Files

    Eduard Mallorqui

    Log File: Replay Fidelity="1"
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty: Warning for Log Infraction

    Elia Costa

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Emre Uysal

    Log File: Ok
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Fabricio Teidy


    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: n/a
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty: See Incident #3 and #4

    Ferry Koek

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: n/a
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Gabriele Del Piccolo

    Log File: .tmp log corrupted
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Cut Lap 14
    Launch-Control: not used
    Penalty: DQ for not using Launch-Control, 0.5 Penalty Points for Pit Exit Cut

    Ivan Kaloyanov

    Log File: Ok
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Jacques Olivier

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Jan-Moritz Kammann

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: n/a
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Kerem Gocen

    Log File: Rearview="0", Save All Replay Sessions="0"
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty: Warning for Log Infraction

    Kevin Brents

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Mark Aalberts

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Mark Johnston

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Martin Gosbee

    Log File: Ok
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Mihajlo Vicentijevic

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Pedro Melim

    Log File: Ok
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Roslan Gaidargi

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Cut Lap 24
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty: 0.5 Penalty Points for Pit Exit Cut

    Sami Pesari

    Log File: Ok
    Pre-Qualifying: Clean
    Qualifying: Clean
    Pit-Exit: Ok
    Launch-Control: used
    Penalty:

    Incident #1 Vicentijevic - Pesari | Lap 1, Turn 1

    Description: Braked way too late Vicentijevic hits Pesari who lost Front and Rearwing.

    Verdict: 1 Penalty Point for Vicentijevic

    Incident # 2 Uysal - Roberts | Racetime: 3:58

    Description: Roberts brakes late, hits Uysal who gets damage.

    Verdict: Race incident

    Incident #3 Teidy - Lawal | Racetime: 6:46

    Description: Teidy tries to overtake on a place where overtaking just is not possible. As a consequence he hits Lawal who spins off, loses rear wing and has to retire. Afterwards
    Teidy makes a completely unsafe return on track, not minding the traffic which causes massive collision forcing several cars to retire and other pit for new wings.

    Verdict: 1 Penalty Point for Teidy for the hit to Lawal

    Incident # 4 Teidy | Racetime: 6:46

    Description: Unsafe return to the track causing in a massive collision forcing to serveral cars to retire and other pit for new wings.

    Verdict: 2 Races Raceban

    Incident # 5 Melim - Piccolo | Racetime: 28:01

    Description: Piccolo having ignored blue flags for a several previous turns, misjudges the situation and goes into a way of Melim who suffers front suspension damage and loses crucial time that costs him another incident.

    Verdict: Seems that Piccolo wanted to clear the racing line for lapping. Which seems to be the idea of both drivers. Next time a bit more careful.
    Warning for clearing the racing line in a difficult way which caused in a small touch for both cars.

    Incident # 6 Melim - Pesari | Racetime: 28:13

    Description: Pesari misses the braking point and hits the race leader Melim who gets rear damage and loses the lead.

    Verdict: 1 Penalty Point for Pesari
     
  2. Just a question ...

    Why Teidy has 2 race bans for a unsafe return causing some crashes, and Tali in WC (Turkey) hadn't any race ban for a similar move ?
     
  3. I did use lauch control. Plus with cars infront of me not moving I couldnt move anyway... then i got forced onto the curb and then into wall a few laps later. I think the DQ is unfair
     
  4. Gauss got a race ban for a hit on purpose in Canada. In my opinion Teidy´s move was more than unfair or brainless. Thats why i gave him a 2 race raceban.

    Chris, i dont think you did use the LC. But i can review it again.
     
  5. I am not saying that the penalty isn't fair, I just want to know why two similar manouvers has that big differences on their penaltys (Tali 2 penalty points, Teidy 2 race ban).

    They did the same (very unsafe return to the track). I know that WC has a different race director, but I can't understand that ...
     
  6. I have the final decision about incidents. And in my opinion i cant give him a less harsh penalty than this.
     
  7. I know, Stefan, I think the penalty is good. What I want to know is why the criteria (is it correct?) of the Race Directors is so different.
     
  8. Sami Pesari

    Sami Pesari
    Premium Member

    hmm so 1 penalty point for hitting race leader slightly and 1 penalty point for completely missing braking point that causes serious damage and wing loss to 2 cars? im not saying that me nor jan was in race winning pace and even worse with bad qualifying but if your penalty system going how good driver you take out i think that was 2 cars from top10 other even from top 5 out
     
  9. Im sorry, but I cant accept this one here:

    He crashed Sami and because of that Sami crashed into my car and my race was over from that. And that was not way too late, that was extremely too late.....

    Second I dont understand is in Quallifying Alberto de Juan was driving with 160L - race fuel in Quallifying and destroyed my last lap, where I have been -0.3 in my last sector!!!!!

    Edit2: Due to request by David Dominguez, I removed the private message.





    EDIT: He blocked me all 3rd sector long, he had so many opportunitys to let me pass!
     
  10. i did press my lc button but as i said when the lights went out the guys in front of me didnt move i waited to move so didnt cause no problems so guess didnt register..
     
  11. Jan, this is a private conversation. Try to edit the message, and if you want to review, send it to the race director :tongue:
     
  12. Stefan,

    I sent all my files thru the file submit tool. It said it was succesful.
    I then posted that in the forum that i used the file submot tool #1.

    Thank you, Danny Roberts
     
  13. Danny I reckon seeing your files in the WS folder, would explain why Stefan didn't receive them.
     
  14. David if you remember Rasmus incident was unfortunate.He hit the astroturf on the run off which spun him onto the racing line so you really cannot compare that incident to what teidy did in valencia.