Monza GP: AMS vs AC

[ouvert]

I did a little "not realy comparison" video of Monza in AMS and AC ..
Obviously lightening on car model is better in AC, AMS leaves AC behind in sound department and tracks quality is about the same .. Patrick did a great job in my opinion ...
Pls ignore the driving .. did three laps in both sims trying to mach the laptimes .. didn`t really work Monza onboard and Spa in modern openwheelers already recorded ...

Monza GP

Nurburgring GP

Barcelona GP

 

[P*Funk]

That's generally why I think the best mod tracks are made by teams that do very few releases.

 

[ouvert]

And Barcelona

 

[ouvert]

And newly released Bathurst for AMS

 

[roby13]

u can produce almost the same graphics in gmotor2 ams' state. materials and shaders optimizing require a lot of hard work

 

[ouvert]

@roby13 well if somebody will create shaders that improve AMS I`ll be happy to use them, until than AMS looks good to me but ACs more modern graphics engine makes it looks better in most cases (not more natural with default settings though) .. not my intention to compare graphics engines in those vids anyway

 

[ouvert]

AC mod track and AMS original track for a change: Suzuka

 

[SCE_SR]

AC mod track and AMS original track for a change: Suzuka

Thats a perfect example how good Reiza's maps really are. The realistic lighting in AC...,ok (i dont like it, too much for me, but anyway), but in the details is AMS's Suzuka much better. Sorry for all AC lovers..

Look at 0:19 - the grass borderline in AC looks terrible edgy, and look the same in AMS.., next 0:51 - the trees in AC, is that beauty or realistic, not really. And there some more not flattering details in AC maps.
For me, details like this are much more important for a good looking map and in this fact Reiza is very good in front or beside the best looking sims. Realistic lighting is not all.

Im very graphic oriented too, but a game like AMS is so much better in most facts. R3E was my graphic favorite, but since AMS i dont spend a view to R3E anymore. Its crazy.

 

[roby13]

last video proves exactly that even a better graphics engine cant do wonders with unoptimized materials. except shadows, ams suzuka looks also better to me.

 

[ouvert]

hmm .. it shows that suzuka AC mod is bellow qualitty of modded tracks that Patricks is giving us .. there are few good looking modded tracks for AC too ..

What is suprising me though since I start with these videos - jumping from game to game within few minutes is how bad AC feels to me now ... which i`m not happy about .. I always liked AC feeling and if I run something with softer suspension and low aero (road cars, low aero historic openwheelers) I still get the joy but with high downforce, modern, stiffer cars feeling is dumbed, disconected .. I didn`t change anything on my side

 

[SCE_SR]

The same with my R3E and AMS. (i have bought stuff for over 100,-€ for R3E)
I think its a question of taste. When a new game hits your taste so much better, you dont want to go back.

 

[Will Mazeo]

There is an angry AC fan that is always downvoting your videos

 

[ouvert]

The same with my R3E and AMS. (i have bought stuff for over 100,-€ for R3E)
I think its a question of taste. When a new game hits your taste so much better, you dont want to go back.

well I do want to enjoy all my sims

There is an angry AC fan that is always downvoting your videos

downvoting where ? I don`t follow these things ... those vids aren`t even anti-AC

 

[David Dominguez]

What is suprising me though since I start with these videos - jumping from game to game within few minutes is how bad AC feels to me now ... which i`m not happy about .. I always liked AC feeling and if I run something with softer suspension and low aero (road cars, low aero historic openwheelers) I still get the joy but with high downforce, modern, stiffer cars feeling is dumbed, disconected .. I didn`t change anything on my side

It's not really surprising

 

[ouvert]

I know you have issues with some aspects of ACs physics, David .. I have some reservations too .. but after patch fixing SAT it felt fairly good .. specialy some cars.

 

[St3fan]

There is an angry AC fan that is always downvoting your videos

Not necessary an AC fan. Most likely someone who hates both.