if you could rank the physics......

[Msportdan]

in rre among the top sim games at this point where would you put it.
heres mine:-
1.GScE
2.RF2
3.Iracing
4.AC
5.RRexperience
6.Pcars (havent played so cant judge)

Just to note, i think gsce and rf2 are very close but, as i think the ffb in Gsc is better i prefer the feeling and handling.
Please rank your thoughts

 

[Connor Caple]

I'm rating PHYSICS here as in how the car behaves on the track, not how it feels at the wheel

1. R3E
2. rF2
3. AC
4. Race 07(Race On/GTR Evo/etc.)
5. iRacing

Going by how much I enjoy the FFB/driving them then it would be:

1. R3E
2. Race 07
3. AC
4. rF2
5. iRacing

 

[ouvert]

1. gsce
2. r3e
3. gtr evo
4. AC
5. iRacing
6. pCars
.
.
50. Grid Autosport

in regards of feeling, ffb and enjoyment
1. gsce, gtr evo, r3e
2. AC
3. rest of mentioned

havent play rf2 and pCars only for few hours and disliked iRacing after short time .. pCars is hit or miss, very depends on car - track combination..
Gtr evo. is with edited ffb settings

 

[Heppsan]

1. R3E
2. Race 07 (all addons)
3. iRacing
4. AC
5 GSC (Haven't played this for quite some time, and not enough to really judge it properly)

 

[shardshunt]

Physics:
1 AC
2 R3E
3 IRacing
FFB:
1 R3E
2 IRacing
3 AC

 

[Sean Kenney]

I don't see how they could truly be ranked unless you have driven that race car, or have a lot of racing experience.

Other than that I just go by what I think feels right.

 

[James Cook]

All I know is R3E and GSC are the most enjoyable.

 

[Emilio]

To my liking R3E delivers an overall better experience compared to the other sims I've tried so far (AC, GSC, Race 07 and GTR2). I'd also say that most of it comes from the sound engine and the actual race feeling. FFB is good (for the most recent released cars) and physics are solid. Looking at the current situation with the other sims right now, i think that If they play their cards right and keep listening to the community as they're doing I think that R3E will come down like a rolling boulder noone was really expecting!

 

[Greg Latty]

1 gran turismo
2 Mario Kart
3 Forza
4 everything else

 

[maxel]

To my liking R3E delivers an overall better experience compared to the other sims I've tried so far (AC, GSC, Race 07 and GTR2). I'd also say that most of it comes from the sound engine and the actual race feeling. FFB is good (for the most recent released cars) and physics are solid. Looking at the current situation with the other sims right now, i think that If they play their cards right and keep listening to the community as they're doing I think that R3E will come down like a rolling boulder noone was really expecting!

Totally agree
Tried AC a few weeks ago just to check out what everyone is talking about and i'm not impressed. R3E's lively combination of physics and FFB plus the awesome sound spoiled me. It's just more fun.

 

[Bryan O'Connor]

1. Euro Truck Simulator 2
2. Goat Simulator
3. Train simulator 2014
4. Grass Simulator

 

[luxtpm]

yeah something i find disappointing from sims its that there are not two alike concerning physics and as i havent driven a race car really cant tell which model is closer

 

[Greg Latty]

Ok here's my real list:
1. R3E
2. GSCE (only higher than ac because I can change realfeel on the fly)
3. AC
4. Gtr2 <> RBR tie
5. Everything else. Haven't played pcars or rf2 (besides the demo)

 

[Greg Latty]

yeah something i find disappointing from sims its that there are not two alike concerning physics and as i havent driven a race car really cant tell which model is closer

I think that's a good thing. If they all felt the same that would get boring. We have a lot of variety.

 

[Shovas]

I think people are rating the subjective feel of force feedback here not the realism of the physics. R3E does indeed 'feel' quite good with force feedback but that says very little about whether physics matches reality or not.

 

[Marco Versele]

GSCE
R3E
AC
RF2
LFS (only fictional cars)

 

[Connor Caple]

I think people are rating the subjective feel of force feedback here not the realism of the physics. R3E does indeed 'feel' quite good with force feedback but that says very little about whether physics matches reality or not.

That's why I made two lists...

 

[budlix]

Mine, generally:

1. GSCe
2. R3E
3. fTruck
4. AC

 

[Bez]

1. GSCE
2. rF2
3. AC
4. R3E

 

[ouvert]

I don't see how they could truly be ranked unless you have driven that race car, or have a lot of racing experience.

lot of mentioned sims have road cars and since most of us probably have thousands and thousands miles behind steering wheel of different cars there is something you can build your opinion on in regards of realism of physics ..